How My Life Got 100x Better When I Stopped Thinking About Google
This is part of a series. The sourced record: The Google Record.
I started building niche websites in 2020. Within a few months, Google became the single biggest factor in my professional life, above my skills, my ideas, and the quality of my work.
When 80% of your visitors come from one source, and that source can change its mind overnight with zero explanation, it shapes everything: what you write, how you write it, what you build, what you don't build. It's not a tool you use, it's a landlord you try to keep happy.
I never went down the hardcore SEO rabbit hole. Didn't build link networks or spin content or buy expired domains. I dabbled in some grey-hat stuff early on, nothing dramatic, mostly things that existed in the grey zone between "Google says don't" and "everyone does it anyway." But the core of what I did was straightforward: write useful content, design it well, actually test the products I reviewed.
For a while, this worked. My main site, Start24, became the best resource in its niche: WordPress and web hosting reviews for Dutch beginners. Honest ratings, beautiful design, well-structured guides, fun to read. Start24 was and is a good site. Readers told me. Competitors knew it.
Core updates came and went. I wasn't obsessively checking Search Console during them (that's a level of anxiety I don't need) but I was generally relaxed. Good site, good content, good rankings. The system seemed to work.
Then last year's core update hit, and Start24's traffic collapsed. The kind of decline where you watch the chart and wonder if the Y-axis is broken.
The money hurt. But what hurt more was the quiet assumption that if you do good work, the system recognizes it. That assumption died in about a week.
I build things I'm proud of. When the best site in a niche gets algorithmically buried while thin affiliate spam sits comfortably on page one, it doesn't just hurt the business. It makes you question whether quality ever mattered at all, or whether you were just lucky for a while.
There's a Japanese concept called mono no aware: a gentle awareness that everything passes. I think about it more than I expected to. More on that here.
I tried things. Deleted content that was less directly relevant, the standard recovery advice. There was a small recovery starting in January. Enough to think maybe the system could still correct itself.
Then in February I went further. Way further. I rebuilt Start24 from the ground up. Interactive content. Custom tools that actually help people make decisions. Radical honesty in reviews: not "every product is great in its own way" but "this one is bad and here's why." A free WordPress video course. A free WordPress theme I built myself. Dramatically better design across the board.
And Google's response? Keywords dropped. Traffic fell again.
I made the site significantly better (more useful, more honest, more complete) and Google decided it deserved to rank lower.
The full story of what happened, and what I saw happen to others, became its own piece.
At some point during this process, something shifted. I stopped caring. Not in a dramatic way. I just noticed, one morning, that I hadn't checked Search Console in weeks.
Start24 was getting traffic through other channels. Google Search Ads turned out to work well for targeted keywords, and the economics made sense in a way that organic never did: predictable cost, predictable return. Direct visits were growing. Email was small but loyal. The site was doing fine. Not because of Google's algorithm. Despite it.
Google occupies more mental space than you realize when you depend on it. Every piece of content you write, there's a voice in the back of your head: will Google like this? Is this the right keyword density? Should I add another section to match the top-ranking pages? It's not conscious optimization. It's a low-grade anxiety that colors everything you do. Once that lifted, the work got better immediately, because I was making decisions for readers instead of crawlers.
I still check the rankings occasionally. Not out of hope, out of curiosity.
Because at this point, Start24's trajectory is fascinating. The site keeps getting better. The rankings keep getting worse. How long can the best site in a niche keep dropping? What does the chart look like when quality and rankings move in perfectly opposite directions?
I'm going to keep tracking this publicly. Not because I think Google will notice or care, but because it's a useful data point in a larger conversation about whether Google search still works. I have some thoughts on that. They'll get their own post.
Here's the practical side, because "I stopped caring" isn't a strategy.
What actually works now: Google Search Ads. Ironic, paying Google to reach people that Google's algorithm decided I don't deserve to reach organically. But the economics work. I control the spend, I can measure the return, and nobody's algorithm can pull the rug at 2am on a Tuesday.
What's building slowly: direct traffic, email, word of mouth. These are small numbers compared to what organic search used to deliver. But they compound, and they belong to me. Nobody can take an email list away with a core update.
What changed the psychology: AI blew the door open. Google used to feel like the front door of the internet. If you weren't in Google, you didn't exist. That's not true anymore. People find things through ChatGPT, through Perplexity, through recommendations in Discord servers and group chats. The web is fragmenting, and for small publishers, that's the best thing that could have happened. More doors means less power behind any single one.
I still can't prove this with data. It's gut feeling backed by early signals. But for the first time in years, the trajectory feels right.
I write what I want now. I design pages for readers, not for crawlers. I add features because they're useful, not because they might improve "time on page" or whatever the SEO community has decided matters this quarter.
The work is more fun. The results are better.
Google is the biggest source of web traffic on earth. It matters. It's also a terrible thing to build your life around.
The liberation isn't in pretending Google is irrelevant. It's in arranging things so that its decisions don't control yours. Diversify your traffic. Build an audience that knows your name, not just your URL. Make things good enough that people come back without being told to by an algorithm.
And then, when Google buries the best site in a niche while promoting garbage, you can watch it happen with curiosity instead of dread.
That's the 100x improvement.
In how it feels to wake up and do the work.
This is part of a series about Google and search. The next piece is I Watched Google Kill Their Websites. The sourced record: The Google Record.
If you want to know when I write something new: